Back to blog

Plug-in hybrids: even old coal is better than gasoline (but renewables are best of all)


All the cool kids have been linking to a new report that concludes plug-in hybrids are a potentially significant source of greenhouse gas reductions if adopted on a wide scale in the United States. This conclusion is not surprising — conventional wisdom has favored plug-ins for a while — but the study’s use of sophisticated models and scenario analysis puts some hard figures around the possible benefits.

Plug-in hybrids, as you probably know, are a form of hybrid-electric vehicle that you can charge by plugging into a wall socket. Although not yet commercially available, the technology is not exotic. You can buy a conversion kit for your Prius for about $10,000.

Update: The cost of a conversion kit does not indicate the cost to an average car buyer. The study projects trends out to 2050. When plug-ins are mass produced, assume that the vehicles will cost roughly the same as gasoline-powered cars do today.

The report mapped out nine different scenarios by varying both the market penetration of plug-ins and the carbon intensity of the U.S. electrical grid. In even the most pessimistic scenario, plug-ins result in significant emissions reductions. In the median (and presumably most likely) scenario, plug-ins shave about half a gigaton of carbon from annual U.S. emissions. To put this in perspective, this is about 10% of the reductions we need to stabilize the climate. Not bad.

The study’s authors also modeled changes to air quality under each scenario. One criticism of plug-ins is that, by shifting fuel consumption from cars to electric utilities, they potentially concentrate particulates and other nasty emissions in certain geographical areas. The study mostly allays these concerns. A small number of areas do see an increase in pollutants, but the large majority of the U.S. will experience a meaningful improvement in air quality.

Because plug-ins run mostly on electricity, their environmental benefit depends heavily on the carbon intensity of the grid. If your local grid is powered by old coal plants, plug-ins actually emit slightly more emissions than regular hybrids (but still far less than conventional cars). In aggregate, though, plug-ins are somewhat better than hybrids using even today’s grid, and the benefits quickly grow larger if we assume future legislation further tilts energy production towards cleaner technologies.

This is a story we like a lot for two reasons that don’t get emphasized often enough: the first is that plug-ins are commercially realizable in the very near term. We can’t wait for exotic technologies to save us from climate change. The second is that plug-in hybrids don’t require significant changes to consumer behavior. Somewhat perversely, some environmentalists see this as a negative. We don’t. The more comparatively easy reductions in greenhouse gas emissions we can find, the better.

Stay in Touch

Never Miss a Thing

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Join the TerraPass newsletter to stay updated, receive conservation tips, analysis of the latest news and insightful opinions. Get started now!

Thanks for subscribing!

Follow us on Twitter

Follow us on Facebook