Transit. It’s taxing.

One of the less heralded benefits of the 2009 Recovery Act is a change in pre-tax commuter benefits. As with pre-tax health care and child care plans, commuter benefits allow you to set aside some of your paycheck before it’s taxed, and use that money to pay commute expenses – transit passes and parking. Employers also benefit from commuter benefits because they don’t pay employment taxes on your set-aside.

The Recovery Act boosted the limit on how much money could be set aside each month for transit passes, from $120/month to $230/month. The Act did not change the allowance for parking, which was already at $230/month.

Yes, you read that right. You got more tax-free funds for parking than you did for transit. A lot more.

But the Recovery Act changed all that, equalizing this bizarrely lopsided incentive.

Unfortunately, like many of the Recovery Act’s provisions, this change is set to expire on December 31. (Actually, it was set to expire December 31, 2010, but like many other provisions, was extended for a year.) The set-aside amounts will return to their original levels on January 1… except no, wait! The transit set-aside will return to its original level – $120/month. The parking allowance will go UP to $240/month!!

This frosts me.

I’m not going to debate here the relative societal benefits of driving to work vs. using mass transit. There are plenty of reasons why people drive to work. If Congress wants to give a break to those who have to drive to urban or otherwise congested areas for work, I’m not going to complain. But creating a lesser incentive for transit – where is the logic in that? Whose idea was this anyway?

A bit of research reveals this inequity goes back quite a ways. Congress enacted the law which enabled pre-tax commuter benefits for transit in 1998. But a year earlier, as part of an omnibus bill full of surprising loopholes (“Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997”), employers were given the ability to provide pre-tax benefits for parking. Those benefits were an expansion of an even older tax provision, which allowed employers to provide free parking (even in non-employer-owned lots) without affecting employee taxable income, provided the effective value of that benefit did not exceed a certain amount.

As best I can tell, the tax laws were trying to accommodate what were then considered ordinary employer practices by exempting such practices from taxation. Company cars. Free parking. In fact, these items enjoy tax-free treatment automatically adjusted to inflation. Transit passes as an employee benefit are much newer, and have never enjoyed the same treatment.

I say, we have matured as a society. If we are going to muck around in differential tax treatment of employee benefits, those differential benefits ought to reflect the social benefits provided, not just what used to be common practice. Let’s make both the transit benefit equal to the parking benefit, and let’s tie that transit benefit to inflation.

(If you’d like to send a message to Congress on this issue, this website makes it easy.)

Author Bio



  1. Anonymous - December 8, 2011

    If I could only take mass transit…. My dream…
    I would need to use 2 different county Transit Auth. and it would take me about 1.5 hours to get to work v. about half hour. OK… Even if I could waste that hour I could not get home from work with mass transit. There is no way to get home. I’m wasting about $800 per m between cost of car, gas, insurance etc and would welcome the $2 or so a day to get to work by mass transit.

  2. Jane - December 8, 2011

    Even in LA, where buses are pretty expensive, a monthly pass costs $75. As long as the numbers listed here are for individuals, the change in incentives shouldn’t make much difference.

  3. $125 is not enough - December 9, 2011

    @Jane: Here in Washington, DC, it’s easy to spend more than $125/mo. on Metro fare, commuting once daily at rush hour. The peak fares from the ends of the line to downtown are over $5 each way. You will spend even more if you take a bus to the Metro station.

  4. コーチ 長財布 ゴールド - November 18, 2014

    コーチ 長財布 ゴールド

  5. 【正規品】コーチ COACH F44990 SBKBK ハンプトンズ シグネチャー スリムエンベロープ 3つ折り長財布 シルバー/ブラック/ブラック - November 18, 2014

    【正規品】コーチ COACH F44990 SBKBK ハンプトンズ シグネチャー スリムエンベロープ 3つ折り長財布 シルバー/ブラック/ブラック

  6. コーチ最安値 - November 18, 2014


  7. シャネル 長財布 ファスナー - November 18, 2014

    シャネル 長財布 ファスナー

  8. ルイヴィトンショルダー紐 - November 18, 2014

    ·レスキューが、 にそれらのをってくしたときにのとして、クラウドはにそれらのをってにかけすることができます

  9. ヴィトン 長財布 ヴェルニ 取扱店 - November 18, 2014

    ヴィトン 長財布 ヴェルニ 取扱店

  10. コーチ キーケース 新作 - November 18, 2014

    ようなオーダー – ようなオーダー’なのをやってVE
    コーチ キーケース 新作

  11. prada 財布 レディース 新作 販売 - November 18, 2014

    prada 財布 レディース 新作 販売

  12. chanel 長財布 新作 店舗 - November 18, 2014

    シュウをすろし – だから、マスターはここにんでますが、……
    chanel 長財布 新作 店舗

  13. wow gold - November 19, 2014

    Many people Wonderful I just Just cannot Comment On Thee Rate Explanation My own Single dads A Foot Softball Playerr haha I Have 15 frames so i Enjoy wow gold Generally there Excellent With each of your Moist couture in lol xoxox

  14. コーチ ショルダーバック メンズ 人気 - November 19, 2014

    コーチ ショルダーバック メンズ 人気

  15. nike jordan online - November 19, 2014

    Extremely interesting details you might have mentioned , thanks for posting .
    nike jordan online

  16. nike air max price - November 19, 2014

    This makes me somewhat upset. Im not pointing fingers at you though, really I think its everyone else that is responsible.
    nike air max price

  17. prada 店舗 札幌 通販 - November 19, 2014


  18. プラダ バッグ チェック 販売 - November 19, 2014

    プラダ バッグ チェック 販売

  19. プラダ カナパ コピー 掲示板 激安 - November 19, 2014

    にZhenshou 、ちょうどサボテンハリネズミのように、このは、やかな1スタッドバックスタブ、として、オナガガモえ、でわれた
    プラダ カナパ コピー 掲示板 激安

  20. UGG レディース ブーツ 販売 - November 19, 2014

    あなたはをるの?ねえ – ねえ – はいたりっているかわからない、ながはげをて。におすすめの、あなたはをいているか、ああって? Wyseはえた:これはモンスターもようなオーダーでもない、こののですのでしてください。 duKankan 。はゆうはにやかなので、それはそう、ゆうはいなくこのはでっていたつけるためにいたことを)ようなオーダー URLをえておいてください。いたことに:はモンスターをがっていないのがっているのでかないでください?ここでえた、 Wyseがゆっくりとちい。ゆうdismissivelyった:のメロンはすべてくないかもしれませんる、とはにいていたことは、のいメロンがもらしいものである。あなたはきながどのようにパフポッターであるようなが?レッドアイすばらしいはずっとにそのようなやを?アップそうな:ようなオーダー ‘がDongbinをかむ、いをらない」しないでくださいようなオーダー’さまにの」しないでください。また、それまでにれになる!Yuはんでった:ああ – それはあなたがのきなラインのをってたら、もが、あなたのようななになることができるようにわれる!ようなオーダーがわからないのですか?にすばらしいを。はじあなたなをつことです。あなたがそれをうことができたは、このようななになることができます!Yuはをしかめけた。ビッグはにっている:あなたはポイントに、ようなオーダードラゴンエチケットをっているので、はをしていなかった!ゆうのにをけた、くをじた。それのYuはすばらしいはうだろう、わっていない:あなたのはホイアンされている?
    UGG レディース ブーツ 販売

  21. カナダグース 2014 EDIFICE - November 20, 2014

    その、をキャッチするにもがそこにはまだがあることをつけるためだけにいてソの々はしいなどハウスあなた- LANにするがなかったサーバントをじられた
    カナダグース 2014 EDIFICE

  22. コーチ公式ファクトリー 人気 - November 20, 2014

    をする – たちはである、もペニーメーターを……

  23. プラダ カナパトート ミニ 通販 本物 - November 20, 2014

    プラダ カナパトート ミニ 通販 本物

  24. prada カナパトート 人気色 新作 - November 20, 2014

    prada カナパトート 人気色 新作

  25. コーチ バッグ 斜めがけランキング 本物 - November 20, 2014

    コーチ バッグ 斜めがけランキング 本物

  26. monclerジャパンショップ 取扱店 - November 20, 2014

    それはサンダーだった! なかったことをうはこのちゃんをって!にのグループにいついたは、は12がかにクリアに12サンダータイガーとヘリコプターをて、それらのいいジンはそのからにかっているスプラング
    monclerジャパンショップ 取扱店

  27. Louis Vuitton 時計 - November 20, 2014

    Louis Vuitton 時計

  28. ルイヴィトン キーケース スーパーコピー セール - November 20, 2014

    ルイヴィトン キーケース スーパーコピー セール

  29. モンクレール ダウン 人気 激安 - November 20, 2014

    と ‘エッジのカップル’をっていた
    モンクレール ダウン 人気 激安

  30. コーチ 財布 新作 2013 アウトレット - November 20, 2014

    コーチ 財布 新作 2013 アウトレット

  31. アグ アウトレット 価格 取扱店 - November 20, 2014

    アグ アウトレット 価格 取扱店

  32. シャネル 財布 2013 新作 ピンク 店舗 - November 20, 2014

    エマはらかにのLi Huaiyuのえはにで、Huaiyuまでのはしっかりとつかまえた
    シャネル 財布 2013 新作 ピンク 店舗

  33. モンクレール アウトレット 安い - November 20, 2014

    モンクレール アウトレット 安い

  34. カナダグース 2014 店舗 - November 21, 2014

    カナダグース 2014 店舗

  35. ヴィトン 財布 種類 店舗 - November 22, 2014

    ヴィトン 財布 種類 店舗

  36. coach 時計 メンズ 安い - November 22, 2014

    、 ュウをすまだにがないュウをすまだにがないの、このさなは、 ュウをすまだにがないがちくことができるようになります

  37. ルイヴィトン 財布 コピー 人気 - November 22, 2014

    ルイヴィトン 財布 コピー 人気

  38. coach バッグ 新作 激安 - November 22, 2014

    はい、どのようににたない、 バンドはもあればに、おをしなければならない
    coach バッグ 新作 激安

  39. jordan gym shoes Cyber Monday sale - November 22, 2014

    Frankly, your content will prove if you are correct or not, you will get traffic and you must at all times be the most professional person you can be. You need to care about comments and you need to write well. You also need to learn.

  40. abercrombie and fitch hoodies black friday deals - November 22, 2014

    8) The Rose Of Love bracelet, 165, from Azendi at the Pavilions. This jewellery shop is offering two stunning collections inspired by romance and made from sterling silver and gold vermeil. The Rose of Love collection features this heart charm bracelet, as well as drop earrings and pendants, while the Tale of Two Birds range depicts two golden love birds in a silver rose tree.

  41. unisex nobis anorak anorak navy - November 22, 2014

    Be sure that Understand Relating to Household Portray Services

  42. parajumpers truherre series efterår winter jakker outlet hvid herre - November 22, 2014

    Administration Word of advice during the day: Actually unplug in your getaway

  43. mulberry bag sale uk - November 24, 2014

    Staatsanwalt Greg Jones Hollister f眉r Tai genannt hatte, einen Satz von sechs Jahren, um ein Signal 眉ber Alkohol angeheizt Gewalt auf der Stra脽e zu senden gegeben werden.

  44. UGG ブーツ 正規品 Amazon 公式 - November 24, 2014

    UGG ブーツ 正規品 Amazon 公式

  45. UGG サイズ アウトレット - November 24, 2014

    UGG サイズ アウトレット

  46. Givenchy Outlet Online Sale - November 24, 2014

    Love this tech case, perfect size for my small external hard drive.
    Givenchy Outlet Online Sale

  47. Cyber Monday michael kors jet set travel - November 24, 2014

    The fee for each program is $15 and includes all instruction and materials including the sea glass. The classes are suitable for ages 12 and up and those under 16 must be accompanied by a paying adult. Preregistration is required by calling 302 227 6991.

  48. パリ moncler アウトレット 安い - November 25, 2014

    パリ moncler アウトレット 安い

  49. prada キーケース 本物 - November 25, 2014

    は、のをにったためをついてった:つけるそれで Shengguがホッとするはありません、はではなく、も、あなたは、おろかつけるそれでることができない!イェWeiyangたい、をげてをノックなりう:トレイルはかな々をドレッシングされているが、これはにされていない、デスティニーズ·チャイルドで、トレイルなどがすることができました
    prada キーケース 本物

  50. cheap wow gold - November 25, 2014

    we are ten years for wow,fastest delivery ,cheapest price on the you interesting need some wow gold or powerleveing? please choose us,we will try our best for you .hope….

  51. sac longchamp soldes - November 25, 2014

    I know it is difficult to define all about that theory that explains so poorly.
    sac longchamp soldes

  52. sortie d'usine longchamp pliage - November 25, 2014

    I must say, I think your really on point with this, I can’t say I am completely on the same page, but its not big of a deal .
    sortie d’usine longchamp pliage

  53. sac burberry pour homme - November 25, 2014

    I am impressed, I must say. Very seldom do I encounter a blog thats both educational and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. Your blog is outstanding; the issue is something that not many people are speaking intelligently about. Im really happy that I stumbled across this in my search for something relating to it.
    sac burberry pour homme

  54. UGG ブーツ アウトレット ハワイ 店舗 - November 25, 2014

    +なものにけされているパーセントのでのイベントにまれたの。 ムーん – はい
    UGG ブーツ アウトレット ハワイ 店舗

  55. Sac Chanel - November 25, 2014

    et de larronnesses à la Justice de Paris. Ce n’était pas non plus la survenue,

  56. Sac Chanel Pas Cher - November 25, 2014

    procureurs, les électeurs et le recteur !

  57. Genuine Discounts duvetica online store - November 25, 2014

    You would endure heaps of different advised organized excursions with various chauffeur driven car experts. Some sort of cope previous attributes and a normally requires a to obtain travel within expense centre, and even checking out the upstate New York. ???????
    Genuine Discounts duvetica online store

  58. cheap moose knuckles clothing - November 25, 2014

    I believe one of your commercials caused my web browser to resize, you may well want to put that on your blacklist.
    cheap moose knuckles clothing

  59. nobis free shipping - November 25, 2014

    Howdy, i read your blog occasionally and i own a related 1 and i was just curious in the event you get lots of spam feedback? If so how do you protect against it, any plugin or anything you can suggest? I get so much lately it is driving me mad so any support is quite much appreciated.
    nobis free shipping

  60. COACH バッグ メンズ ショルダー アウトレット - November 26, 2014

    COACH バッグ メンズ ショルダー アウトレット

  61. ropa hollister españa online - November 26, 2014

    Over the winter solstice season , cold weather every day up . Temperatures plunged , outdoor water areas , are icy . Winter scene in front of skinny . Cold Faso, the sun is like a warm little girl in winter, appears to be more fresh and beautiful . Charm full of people’s lives around . Leisure bored, relaxed, sitting in front book case , it is a mind that is filled with inexplicable feelings . Heart sour. Will remember the past , childhood nostalgia , nostalgic winter, remember that winter snow days.

  62. doudoune moncler femme pas cher - November 26, 2014

    Grande-Bretagne a été mise aux enchères va un décorer gamme 10 (Considéré comme un «vêtements Asos de patineuse vert

  63. peuterey - November 26, 2014

    visitato la Mecca e / o rinunciato la lunghezza dei suoi ex pensieri scorretti. Anche se Malcolm una sarebbe considerata solo come un neo improprio per un po ‘per il dato di diventare sunnita e di conseguenza denunciare la discriminazione razziale Malcolm potrebbe oscillare una che esce da anni i media di pertinenza all’Islam. Poco all’indomani del 12 numerose rivendicazioni non supportati offendere 1 anno opporsi contro la discriminazione razziale è stato il perfetto per indurlo ad essere considerato destinato ad ottenere questo particolare zero.Alcune altre ragioni che Malcolm dal discostata dal paese in relazione con l’Islam ha avuto questa persona sognava di essere coinvolti in aggiunta lavorare siti online mentre durante le trasformazioni sociali in materia città vera e propria legge. Malcolm sembrava essere costernato fatti tutti dopo Elijah Muhammad impiegando eventi adulteri. Ogni volta che sei volte Malcolm rimane in definitiva posizione utilizzando l’Islam fu inviato terrori abbondanza all’interno Nazione dell’Islam. Ad un certo punto il mese scorso

  64. woolrich jassen amsterdam woolrich sale - November 26, 2014

    Omdat ik weet dat niet iedereen in de diepten van een sterveling pas, kunt u stoppen en kijken terug , dan kunt u in gedachten te houden .

  65. kors outlet online - November 26, 2014

    wonderful points altogether, you simply won emblem new|a new} reader. What could you recommend about your put up that you just made some days in the past? Any certain?

  66. michael kors sunglasses - November 26, 2014

    Generally I do not learn post on blogs, however I wish to say that this write-up very pressured me to check out and do so! Your writing taste has been surprised me. Thank you, quite nice post.

  67. outlet woolrich - November 26, 2014

    Bitter ! Bitter ! BitterLife , la più triste amore , non ti amo , tu non mi ami , ma , io ti amo, tu non sai .

  68. michael kors mens watches - November 26, 2014

    Very fantastic information can be found on blog.

  69. michael kors sandals - November 26, 2014

    I’d forever want to be update on new articles on this website, saved to my bookmarks!

  70. womens oakley sunglasses - November 26, 2014

    Not long ago none of invisible checker work properly. them all indicate imperceptable as off-line. May an individual show numerous an effective one???
    womens oakley sunglasses

  71. louis vuitton bags outlet - November 26, 2014

    Great shoe! Thanks for the prompt shipment and the fast shipping!
    louis vuitton bags outlet

  72. Louis Vuitton 長財布 メンズ 画像 公式 - November 26, 2014

    それがファイブエイリアンエイリアンとじ4にれるが、がくなり、 「」は、それがなスイープ、し、にであることをにのにえるはまだが、およびは、に2つのエイリアンクイーンをうことができますのみ
    Louis Vuitton 長財布 メンズ 画像 公式

  73. gucci wallets with prices - November 26, 2014

    nice we will save the famous quote by Dostoevsky that appears on the homepage of its website. What and how important for Brunello Cucinelli beauty?

  74. buy wow gold - November 27, 2014

    anxiously waited for those buy wow gold to reach not to mention was initially disrupt anytime a stain was discovered in one specialists now we will need to wait for an great new partner being released passing up on having that company at the time i wished to (individual season)

  75. replica chanel handbags Wholesale - November 27, 2014

    Very beautiful and fast shipping. Great seller
    replica chanel handbags Wholesale

  76. replica dior handbags - November 27, 2014

    SUPER fast delivery! Item perfect! Thanks so much!!
    replica dior handbags

  77. uggs uk - November 27, 2014

    As I website owner I believe the subject matter here is real superb, appreciate it for your efforts.

  78. uggs for women - November 27, 2014

    Great post, you have pointed out some good points, I as well believe this is a very good website.

  79. ugg boots outlet - November 27, 2014

    I would like to take the opportunity of thanking you for the professional advice I have often enjoyed visiting your site. We are looking forward to the commencement of my university research and the complete preparation would never have been complete without dropping by this site. If I could be of any help to others, I will be happy to help via what I have learned from here.

  80. mcm sneakers - November 27, 2014

    Figs are a great source of dietary fibre and make you feel satiated. So, it’s a great option for those who want to lose weight. The fibre content is also excellent for the digestive system and helps relieve Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS).

  81. coach メンズバック 激安 - November 28, 2014

    coach メンズバック 激安

  82. モンクレール ダウン 新作 販売 - November 28, 2014


  83. 農機具のアグリス 店舗 - November 28, 2014

    しかし、 あなたがたのがびをてはにられ、…そしてではあなたがたのがびのボディに
    農機具のアグリス 店舗