TerraPass blog

Natural Gas Politics book: Gas secure, cost competitive

Tom Arnold | April 5, 2006

 

Natural Gas Politics
If you were enthralled with our recent discussion of farm-based methane, then you may want to add this 300 page tome, edited by TerraPass guest blogger Mark Hayes, to your bedtime reading list.

What does natural gas have to do with climate change? Gas-fired power plants emit less than half the carbon dioxide of coal-burning power plants, and can easily replace old coal plants or handle new demand.

The potential problems with natural gas are high prices and the same energy security concerns that plague oil. If natural gas imports are deemed insecure and expensive, coal becomes more attractive as an alternative. Coal is terrible for the environment, and unfortunately we’re seeing a concerted push for a new generation of coal-burning power plants in the U.S. and Europe.

The authors argue that neither criticism of natural gas is valid. Detailed economic modeling shows natural gas to be cost-competitive with coal, and a political analysis suggests that gas can be supplied securely without risk of an exporters’ cartel.

This is welcome news. To the extent that we must burn fossil fuels, let’s at least focus on the clean ones first.

< Previous: Is sustainability at a tipping point?    Next: Demand Response 101: Efficiency Pools of Power >

Comments


  • 1.

    You say "Gas-fired power plants emit less than half the carbon dioxide of coal-burning power plants" but real data from EPA/DOE inventory of all power plants in the US puts natural gas at 60% of coal. And this is just for CO2; it does not include methane leaks. If we start importing more LNG as the book suggests, the global warming effect of natural gas in the US will go much higher relative to coal than it is today. Natural gas is part of the problem, not part of the solution.


    Reply

The comments section is now closed.


AddThis Feed Button
CATEGORIES

Conservation tips
News
Politics
Science & Technology
Society
TerraPass Answers